Book details of 'Artificial life : A report from the frontier where computers meet biology'
|Title||Artificial life : A report from the frontier where computers meet biology|
Shop for this book
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases
Back to shelf Computer history/fun
The Virtual Bookcase Reviews of 'Artificial life : A report from the frontier where computers meet biology':
Reviewer Rob Slade wrote:
One of the strengths of the LOGO computer language is its suitability for
program constructs involving recursion. Many programming languages have a
number of forms of iteration whereby a routine in the program may loop a number
of times. In recursion, however, separate copies of the program start up using
as input the output of the parent process. The program, in a sense, is alive,
and reproduces itself. Using this tool it is remarkably easy to generate both
graphical and text objects which ape the products of living organisms with
startling fidelity. It is fascinating to do and watch ... but ultimately
The same could be said of this book. Levy has collected anecdotes from the
various areas, mostly computer related, where researchers are trying to imitate
various aspects of life. The material is entertainingly put together and easy
to read. If you wish an introduction to a subset of the people working in
these fields, this is a quick overview that might do it.
If, on the other hand, you are interested in the technology itself, forget it.
Other than some outcomes of experiments, there is almost no technical
information at all. No analysis, either. In the discussion of genetic
algorithms, where programs mate, mutate and are then tested for fitness
determined by a certain task, Levy makes much of the fact that these programs
essentially write themselves. This is, however, simply an extension of the old
Monte Carlo algorithm, whereby the testing of random data eventually gives you
an approximation of the answer to a problem. Both the Monte Carlo and genetic
algorithms are severely restricted in the problems they can be used to solve.
I have been too harsh in my dismissal of the amount of analysis in the book.
Levy does raise the questions that need answers. Such as: What *is* life?
How can we test these systems? Can we control artificial life if we do create
it? Might artificial life be too "expensive" in terms of resources and energy?
One vital question, though, is never considered. When one examines an
apparently life-like machine, one must then decide if a machine can truly live,
or only ape life. If one asserts that machines can live, one is then beset
with a related question: Are we merely biological machines and nothing more?
Levy appears to assume the answer is yes, without ever having raised the
question. In which case his condemnation of programmers who look forward to
our replacement by living machines is decidedly odd.
My primary interest, of course, is in the last chapter, "The Strong Claim."
The strong claim for having created artificial life is, as might be expected,
the computer virus. Unfortunately, the strong claim is not supported by strong
facts. While the section on Fred Cohen's research is interesting, Levy has
done little additional research. His history is quite careless with facts
claiming that the "cookie" prank was a virus. Core Wars is also claimed to be
viral and the 1984 Scientific American article is said to have influenced
programs known to have been written years before. The author of Den Zuk is
said to be Venezuelan, rather than Indonesian, and the derivation of the name
The discussion of viral programs is limited and seems to be merely a lead-in to
talk about the morality of artificial life. This latter subject comprises half
the chapter and, except fleetingly, makes no reference to viral programs at
all. This, and the earlier discussion of Von Neumann machines which reproduce
themselves using materials at hand, bring to mind a Greg Bear novel which is
based upon the destruction of the earth by self-reproducing machines. The
controlling galactic government considers the construction of such machines
automatic grounds for the extermination of a species. Many in the virus
research community might agree, noting that it is inherently impossible to know
what damage self-constructing automata might cause in an unknown environment.
Levy touches on this tangentially in places, but never really examines it.
The book is an amusing diversion. One cannot say that it overstates its claims
because, in the end, it makes no claims. In the end, we are left with the
questions, some interesting biographical points and little else. To quote
Marvin, "Life. Don't talk to me about life."
Reviewer Koos van den Hout wrote:
A good book on the history of the research in artificial intelligence explaining a lot of the basic principles and the history of the field. Recommended for anyone wanting to know more about what AI is.
Add my review for Artificial life : A report from the frontier where computers meet biology