The Virtual Bookcase Reviews of 'Wireless Security: Models, Threats, and Solutions':
Reviewer Rob Slade wrote:
When I was trying to describe this book, a colleague noted that it
sounded like (job) security by distraction. The authors have managed
to string together a number of points about different aspects of
technology, many related to wireless communications and security, but,
overall, not providing the reader with much that is relevant to the
central topic.
Chapter one, entitled "Why is Wireless Different," gives all the
appearance of a political polemic. It sounds good, but analysis
reveals very little actual meaning in the text. Contiguous statements
actually have no relationship to each other. Instead of the promised
material about wireless information warfare, chapter two presents a
random collection of tidbits from communications and security topics.
One table of threats breaks over a number of pages, mixing parts and
becoming completely confused. A proposed "taxonomy" is nothing of the
kind, with a set of completely orthogonal classification factors.
Vulnerabilities of the wired telephone infrastructure and some
completely unrelated material (how to make a spike microphone with a
nail, two thumbtacks, a rubber band and a piezo crystal) leave no room
for anything related to wireless security in chapter three. Chapter
four's discussion of satellite communications, with a side diversion
into generic cryptography and export controls, has no practical use.
Lots of non-computational cryptographic systems and a discussion of
pseudo-random number generators make for a very generic (absent a neat
explanation of Diffie-Hellman key exchange) discussion of cryptography
in chapter five. After a great deal of promotion of products sold by
the authors, there is little space left for any examination of the use
of cryptographic systems in wireless communications. Esoteric trivia
such as linguistic spectral analysis and translation of a specific
date to Mayan format have little to do with cryptography in speech
systems in chapter six. Chapter seven's look at wireless LAN systems
is astonishingly short, with little about protection except for a
terse assertion of the weakness of the WEP (Wired Equivalent Privacy)
protocol. (While there is some detail in the discussion of WEP, there
is no explicit mention of the fact that the initialization vector is
sent in plaintext, that RC4 has known weaknesses, and that
initialization vector generation makes re-use almost inevitable. In
addition there is implicit support for the common marketing
misrepresentation that WEP uses a 64 bit, rather than 40 bit, key.)
In chapter eight we get vague security theorizing rather than a review
of the Wireless Application Protocol (WAP). There is a decent
explanation of SSL/TLS (Secure Sockets Layer/Transport Layer Security)
and a list of other security protocols in chapter nine, but then it
ends with a very poor duplication of the SSL material in dealing with
WTLS (Wireless Transport Layer Security). There is some detailed
examination of the security aspects of the Bluetooth system, in
chapter ten, but it is weakened by the lack of an overall conceptual
framework. Chapter eleven looks at VoIP (Voice over Internet
Protocol), but most of the points are covered elsewhere, and there is
no attempt to explain the relevance to wireless systems. Instead of
hardware considerations for end-to-end security, chapter twelve gives
us random communications topics, some related to hardware and some
not; some related to security and some not. Chapter thirteen is a
detailed promotion for products of the authors.
While there are points of interest and relevance to wireless security
in this book, there is a great deal of irrelevant content, redundant
duplication, and meaningless verbiage. The book, and most of the
chapters, are only barely structured, with nothing in the way of an
overall organization that would make relevant points easy to either
find or understand. Wireless security is an important topic, but this
volume will do very little to help readers achieve mastery of it.
copyright Robert M. Slade, 2002
Add my review for Wireless Security: Models, Threats, and Solutions