The Virtual Bookcase Reviews of 'Web Security & Commerce (O'Reilly Nutshell)':
Reviewer amazon.com wrote:Garfinkel and Spafford, longtime Net veterans, overturn a lot of misconceptions about online security in a commonsense book that is easily accessible to even nontechnical readers. They make it clear that any commercial Web site requires careful attention to security­-even if the site doesn't carry any sensitive information. Furthermore, the authors show that there's a lot more to security than merely encrypting transmissions. Their goal is to lay the foundation for securing the three parts of a system: the Web server and its data; the information that travels between server and user; and the user's own computer and the information stored there. Because of the rapidly evolving nature of Web security, Garfinkel and Spafford are not specific in terms of security flaws and tools to fix them. Instead, they emphasize laying out the Web-security principles that will be applicable throughout several generations of hardware and software change. In the process, they give extensive coverage to user safety, digital certificates, cryptography, Web-server security, and the larger issues of commerce and society. Appendix A shows the lessons of the book in action as it details Garfinkel's experience running and securing the Vineyard.net Internet service provider.
Reviewer Rob Slade wrote:
Anyone who does not know the names Spafford and Garfinkel simply does
not know the field of data security. The authors, therefore, are well
aware that data security becomes more complex with each passing week.
They note, in the Preface, that the book cannot hope to cover all
aspects of Web security, and therefore they concentrate on those
topics that are absolutely central to the concept, and/or not widely
available elsewhere. Works on related issues are suggested both at
the beginning and end of the book.
Chapter one, which is also part one, introduces the topic, and the
various factors involved in Web security. The topic is examined from
the perspective of the user and vendor, and also looks at
vulnerabilities at the server site, client computer, and the network
in between.
Part two concerns the user. Chapter two looks at the various possible
problems with browsers, not all of which are related to Web page
programming. Java security is only marginally understood by many
"experts," and not at all by users, so the coverage in chapter three
is careful to point out the difference between safety, security, and
the kind of security risks that can occur even if the sandbox *is*
secure. ActiveX and the limitations of authentication certificates
are thoroughly explored in chapter four. Chapter five looks briefly
but analytically at the possible invasions of privacy that can occur
on the Web.
Part three deals more completely with the question of digital
certificates. Chapter six explains the various techniques for
identification confirmation. The use of certification authorities is
reviewed in chapter seven, including the activity this can generate on
Web browsers. Chapter eight covers the steps needed to obtain a
client-side digital certificate from Verisign. Microsoft's
Authenticode code signing system is detailed in chapter nine.
Cryptography must be invoked at some point for any kind of data
security, and particularly for security over insecure networks, so
part four invests some depth in the topic. Chapter ten starts with
cryptographic basics, simply in terms of the various functions
cryptography can provide. Functional limitations of cryptography,
various existing systems, and US and international regulation with
respect to the technology are discussed in chapter eleven. SSL
(Secure Sockets Layer) and TLS (Transport Layer Security) are
described in chapter twelve.
Part five details technical aspects of securing Web servers.
Traditional host security weaknesses are reviewed in chapter thirteen.
Chapter fourteen looks at specific strengthening measures for Web
servers. Rules for secure CGI (Common Gateway Interface) and API
(Application Programmer Interface) programming are promulgated in
chapter fifteen, along with tips for various languages.
Commercial and societal concerns are major areas in Web security, so
part six reviews a number of topics related to commerce, as well as
other social factors. Chapter sixteen looks at current non-cash
payment systems, and the various existing, and proposed, digital
payment systems for online commerce. Censorship and site blocking are
carefully examined in chapter seventeen. A variety of legal issues
are discussed, civil in chapter eighteen, and criminal in nineteen.
In reviewing books I very often find that appendices are often filler.
The most useful tend to be bibliographies or lists of vendor contacts.
Too many seem to be mere self-indulgent filler used by the author to
pad out the book. Although it has almost nothing to do with Web
security as such, I very much enjoyed Appendix A, Garfinkel's
recounting of the lessons learned in setting up a small ISP (Internet
Service Provider). (I suppose that this could be considered valid
coverage of Web commerce.) The other appendices are more directly
related to the topic, including information on the installation of Web
server certificates, the SSL protocol, the PICS (Platform for Internet
Content Selection) specification, and references.
In comparison to Stein's "Web Security" I find it
very difficult to choose between the two. Each is readable, and each
is aimed pretty much at the same target audience. There is little to
choose between them for technical depth: each has useful information
that the other does not. Both are excellent: what the heck, buy two,
they're small.
copyright Robert M. Slade, 1998
Add my review for Web Security & Commerce (O'Reilly Nutshell)