The Virtual Bookcase Reviews of 'The Official PGP User's Guide':
Reviewer Rob Slade wrote:
Aficionados of the ironic must dearly love the story of Pretty Good Privacy.
Therefore, it is somehow appropriate that the original, official guide comes as
the last of five, following the books by Stallings (BKPRTPRV.RVW), Garfinkel
(BKPGPGAR.RVW), Schneier (BKEMLSEC.RVW) and Bacard (BKCMPRHB.RVW).
The irony is compounded by the fact that this is basically a printed version of
the documentation included with the (2.6+) freeware version of the program,
and, therefore, presumably has been available for a while.
Still, this work has the advantages of being: (a) the original; and, (b) the
smallest of the five. The details of the program operation are the highest
priority. Those chapters devoted to concepts are brief, but very cogent.
Chapter seven warns against those who are promoting encryption systems which
are either untried or known to be insecure. As Zimmermann points out, it is
impossible to tell whether an encryption algorithm is strong or weak just by
looking at the ciphertext. This is quite apposite to the current marketing of
corporate "groupware," and systems for "digital cash". American companies are
at a serious disadvantage because of U.S. federal regulations--a disadvantage
they try to hide by parading strong algorithms and hiding weak key lengths.
Zimmermann does not go into the details of cryptanalysis as do Stallings,
Garfinkel, and Schneier, but one can have more confidence in his assessment in
chapters ten and eleven than in Bacard's overenthusiastic promises. Those who
know the story might expect a diatribe in chapter twelve, "Legal Issues," but--
in another irony--the restrained "just the facts" presentation is probably a
more effective argument than any commentary could be. Zimmermann is also
prudent in regard to the availability of the freeware version of the program--
but still manages to provide valuable information.
No security library should be complete without this book. And, for those who
are using the freeware program, ordering a copy would both help you and say
thanks to the developer at the same time.
copyright Robert M. Slade, 1995
Add my review for The Official PGP User's Guide