The Virtual Bookcase Reviews of 'Crossing Platforms : A Macintosh/Windows Phrasebook':
Reviewer amazon.com wrote:Say what you like about the farmer and the cowman, but the Windows user and the Macintosh jockey likely will never enjoy much more than a grudging coexistence. That's why it can be so traumatic when a job or other tragic circumstance requires a devotee of one environment to switch to the other. Crossing Platforms: A Macintosh/Windows Phrasebook helps ease the shock by translating the terms and conventions of each platform into the other's equivalent. It's organized like a translating dictionary, with two distinct sections: one for translating "Macintosh" into "Windows," the other for going the opposite way. Someone who is familiar with Windows and wants to know the equivalent of booting into Safe Mode can look up that term in the Windows-to-Mac section and read all about holding down the Shift key to boot Mac OS without extensions. A Mac user can look up Finder in the Mac-to-Windows section and learn how to use the functionally equivalent Windows Explorer. Each section opens with a handy "10 Most Important Differences" section, which explains such things as the operating systems' differences in window anatomy and that whole single- versus multiple-button mouse debacle. There's a certain amount of nyah-nyah sniping about which operating system's features are better, but it's all in fun. This is an honestly useful book. --David Wall Topics covered: Differences between modern Microsoft Windows (Windows 95 and 98) and Apple Mac OS (Mac OS 8 and beyond) operating systems, organized in dictionary format for people looking for the "other" system's equivalents of interface features they know.
Reviewer Rob Slade wrote:
There is no overall preface to this book, so it takes a while to
figure out that it is a dictionary. Or encyclopedia or glossary,
maybe. Two dictionaries, in fact. The first half of the book
translates Mac to Win, and the second half is Win to Mac. Each
section has an almost identical, and very brief, introduction.
Unfortunately, there are few cross-references, and there is no index.
There is a great deal of useful information. "Disk space" points out
that dragging a disk to the trash is the usual way to eject it on the
Mac, but doing the same thing with the Recycle Bin in Windows will
erase the files on the disk. "File synchronization" gives one of the
best explanations I have seen of the mysterious Windows Briefcase.
Some of the terms don't really translate. For example, there is an
entry (in both sections) for "clean install." This makes sense in the
Mac world, but not Windows, where the relevant term is "re-install"
(which isn't even listed in the Windows side). The description makes
it clear that replacing the operating system on Windows is a more
involved process than it is on the Mac, but doesn't point out that the
situation is so radically different that Windows users wouldn't even
recognize the term. ("You talkin' about reformatting?")
In some cases the descriptions leave out valuable information. For
example, the sections on transferring files cover a variety of
methods, but don't discuss the importance of file extensions in
assisting the process. Even the entry for file types fails to list
the common extensions.
There is a definite Windows 98 emphasis. "Folders" is the term used
by both sides, even though most experienced (read "old") Windows users
still talk about directories. There is also a tendency to try to
integrate terms, which leads to entries such as "Passwords Control
Panel" rather than the more recognizable "My Computer|Control
Panel|Passwords." In other places similar functions are not linked if
they aren't identical: Scrapbook makes no mention of Clipboard.
Rather oddly, a number of commercial applications that are available
on both platforms are also listed.
Despite the flaws, this guide is very useful for those with a strong
background on one platform needing an introduction to work with the
other. It can save a lot of time and aggravation.
(Oh, all right. It does have an entry for virus, and it's no good.)
copyright Robert M. Slade, 2000
Add my review for Crossing Platforms : A Macintosh/Windows Phrasebook