The Virtual Bookcase Reviews of 'Minding Your Cybermanners on the Internet':
Reviewer Rob Slade wrote:
Ignoring the "smiley" books (BKSMILEY.RVW and BKSMLDCT.RVW) and one rather
generic guide to grammar, out of the hundreds of books published so far on the
subject of the Internet, this is only the second to be devoted to the etiquette
of network communications (after Shea's "Netiquette", cf BKNTQUTT.RVW). It is
a valuable and worthwhile addition.
Coverage of the topic is very broad-ranging, although it is not, perhaps,
complete. The material is very practical, with lists of do's and don'ts,
summaries, and question-and-answer sections. Rose has a professional grasp of
humour, and it is used extensively and effectively throughout.
The book is not without problems. There is a shortage of explanation of the
"why" on various topics. There is a chapter on how flames start (and a pretty
good one) -- but not until chapter six. Rose recommends against the spread of
"dying child" letters--but doesn't explain the situation behind the Craig
Shergold stories, nor the related "Neiman-Marcus cookie" legend or the "FCC
Modem Tax" rumours. He mentions the frequent administrative mis-posts on
mailing lists, but not how to avoid doing them.
Some specific recommendations are questionable. He suggests the use of
abbreviations and "cyberese" (the acronyms of common phrases, like BTW for "by
the way") as a means of keeping messages short. This is no longer considered
good etiquette, as it is highly confusing to newcomers--and oldtimers as well,
in certain cases. (In fact, the book contradicts itself at this point,
recommending both for and against abbreviations, on a single page.) (Some may
also consider the repeated promotion of Kent's "The Complete Idiot's Guide to
the Internet" (BKIDTINT.RVW) and "The Complete Idiot's Next Step on the
Internet" (sorry, haven't seen it yet) almost to constitute "spamming" within
this book, itself.)
I definitely recommend this work for all Internet users, and particularly
newcomers. I very much hope future editions will extend a work well begun.
copyright Robert M. Slade, 1995
Add my review for Minding Your Cybermanners on the Internet